Thursday, August 26, 2010

Women's Equality Day

Today, August 26, 2010, marks the 90th anniversary of the ratification of the 19th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, giving women the right to vote. I think it's impossible to overstate the importance of this event. So much work led up to it, so much has since been done to further equal rights for women, and so much has yet to be done.

Some highlights of the woman suffrage movement:

Seneca Falls, New York, Women's Rights Convention, 1848--The first organized gathering to demand civil rights for women, including the right to vote.

First State Campaign: Kansas, 1867--Suffragists travel the state for the first of state elections to change the law to allow women to vote.

First Equal Suffrage Territory: Wyoming, 1869. Utah Territory followed suit immediately after Wyoming.

Susan B. Anthony attempts to vote, 1872--Testing the newly amended Constitution after the Civil War, the suffrage leader personally claims, and later eloquently defends, women's right to vote.

Introduction of the Woman Suffrage Amendment, 1878--California Senator A.A. Sargent introduces what will eventually become the 19th Amendment, but it languishes in Congress.

Suffragists lobby Congress, 1878-1919.

First State Victory: Colorado, 1893.

Washington, D.C. suffrage parade, 1913--The demonstration draws national attention when an unruly mob attacks the women and blocks the parade.

Picketing and hunger strikes, 1917--Police are ordered to arrest suffragists picketing the White House but the women refuse to eat or cooperate in jail, forcing the Administration's hand.

The Amendment passes the House of Representatives, 1918, but the Senate defeats it.

Tennessee Ratifies the 19th Amendment, 1920--The final battle after 35 states ratified, waged down to the wire and won by the slimmest of margins; then Secretary of State Bainbridge Colby disregards opponents' objections an signs the final proclamation.

This information came from the Nation Women's History Project. They have lots more information on their website. The following books are also recommended:

In Her Own Right by Elisabeth Griffith
Century of Struggle by Eleanor Flexner
New Women of the New South by Marjorie Spruill Wheeler
Winning the Vote by Robert P.J. Cooney, Jr. (a photographic record)
Harriot Stanton Blatch and the Winning of Woman Suffrage by Ellen Carol Dubois

So, let's celebrate. Anyone for a party?

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

Patten Family Tribute, September 25, Manti

The Manti Camp of the Daughters of the Utah Pioneers invites all descendants of John Patten Sr. and Abigail Stiles and all descendants of John Patten Sr. and Hannah Ingersoll to a "Settlement of Sanpete" Honor Day Tribute on Saturday, September 25, 2010 in Manti, Utah. Details and registration information can be found here.

The activities for that day include tours of the Patten House DUP Museum, drive-by tours of local homes and properties (Patten and Billings), walking tour of family graves in the Manti Cemetery, lunch at the Manti Tabernacle, and a family program in the Tabernacle Chapel honoring the Patten Family and their history.

I see on the schedule that you can register that morning, but I know the planners would love to have some indication in advance of how many to expect. They are also producing a family history book ($20) as part of this event.

I am planning to attend this event and will have copies of Not Just Keeping House available for those who are interested. I'm especially anxious to learn more about this interesting family and meet more cousins (because you really can't ever have too many cousins).

Hope to see some of you there.

Thursday, August 12, 2010

Mormon Women Today

There is an excellent article in today's Salt Lake Tribune about Mormon women today. Check it out at www.sltrib.com/sltrib/lifestyle/50080435-80/women-church-mormon-lds.html.csp .

Thursday, June 10, 2010

Home Again

I'm home from my travels now and I've had a few days to reflect on the whole experience. Overall, it was a life-enriching and life-changing experience which I will be mentally processing for some time to come. For now, here is a short list of things I have learned, in no particular order:
  • I may be old, but I am teachable.
  • There is so much to see and so much to learn in this big wide world that no one person can do it all in one lifetime.
  • I may not be able to do and learn it all, but anything I do and learn is better than doing and learning nothing.
  • Experience is cumulative.
  • Experience is personal.
  • People are influenced by the geography and history of where they live.
  • The westward movement of the United States in the 19th century had a profound effect on the country as a whole, on Westerners as a group and on me as an individual.
  • I am a Westerner, through and through. Yet, I am also linked to my Eastern compatriots by shared American and U.S. history.
  • I love everything about the geology of the West--the mountains, the arid lands, even the sagebrush (and yes, even the cooler weather).
  • I could never be happy living in a hot, humid climate.
  • I love flowers and they are what I miss most about living in Montana.
  • I agree with something I read in my travels, "We love what we know more than we know what we love."
  • I have profound respect for the people who came to and lived in the western U.S. in the 19th century--the Indians, the trappers and mountain men, the prospectors, the Christian missionaries, the Chinese, the Mormons, etc.--all of them.
  • There were many, many reasons why people came west.
  • Every person has a story (or many stories) and every story has several different tellings.
  • There are good people everywhere. Most people want to be friendly and helpful and share what they love with strangers.
  • Most people are understanding of disabilities and try to accommodate, but a few (everywhere) couldn't care less.
  • The world (and the U.S. in particular) is a beautiful place--all of it--the mountains, the prairies, the hills, the flat (really flat) land, the lakes, the rivers, the trees, the flowers, the dirt roads, the rocks, and all of the animals.

I stopped at a lot of historical sites on this trip, some stops planned and some impromptu. One thing I heard consistently from guides at these sites was the phrase, "This is sacred ground." Sometimes it came across as a little pompous, as if this particular ground and the people who lived here were somehow better than all the rest. After a while, it started to sound more than a little trite. But in the end, the conclusion I came to was that it's ALL sacred ground. There is history everywhere. Even here in the West, where I've always thought of settlement as being fairly recent, native peoples have trod the mountains, valleys and trails for centuries. Wherever I go, wherever I wander, others have gone before. People have lived, died, loved, hated and bodies have been buried everywhere. There is no un-sacred ground. And everywhere, events have happened that have affected my life and influenced who I am, how I feel and what I think. I am a part of all of it, and it is all a part of me.

The Battle of the Little Bighorn (more photographs)








Here are some more photographs taken at the Little Bighorn Battlefield National Monument.
From the top: the memorial monument to the Indians with the Crow Indian Reservation in the distance, looking up the hill to the monument and markers for the Cavalry, a view of the mountains from the battle hill (much the same as it would have looked in 1876), the walking trail from the hilltop down to the ravine (where the Indians were camped).
I want to add that I would highly recommend this national monument as a place well worth going out of your way to visit. It isn't far from Billings, MT and is just off the interstate highway. I took a guided walking tour of the hilltop with two Native American park service rangers (one Cheyenne and one Souix). Their knowledge, insite and perspective were truly enlightening and helped me better understand this time in U.S. history. I came away from this experience with more respect for all who were involved--the cavalry men, the Indian Braves, the Indian women and children, the Indian guides and the leaders on all sides. The National Park Service has done a beautiful job of portraying what happened here without taking sides or glorifying the horror of it all.


My Last Stop: Little Bighorn Battlefield, Montana








Photographs: Stone markers where the men fell in battle (the black one marks where Custor fell), looking out over the battlefield, part of the memorial to the Indians, the large memorial to the U.S. Cavalry soldiers (listing their names and placed over the mass grave).


Little Bighorn Battlefield National Monument marks the location of the Battle of Little Bighorn between U.S. Cavalry forces and a coalition of Indian tribes. This battle, which lasted only about three hours, took place on June 25, 1876.

One of the things that was so interesting to me as I followed the Mormon Trail west and visited sites for the Mormon, California and Oregon Trails in Casper, Wyoming was the role the Native Americans (who prefer to be called Indians in our part of the country) played in the westward migration of the white people. It was the Indian trails which formed the basis for the emigrant trails. It was Indian guides who helped the trappers and early explorers find a way through the mountains to the west coast. It was Indians who traded with the white people, allowed them safe passage through their (the Indians') hunting grounds and even stopped to help the handcart pioneers pull their carts up steep slopes.
I grew up hearing stories of Indian attacks and often had nightmares as a child that included graphic visions of painted Braves stampeding their horses down Michigan Avenue while I hid behind the chair in the corner of the living room. The truth is that the westward bound white settlers were in more danger from marauding white men and accidents along the trail than they were from Indian attacks. Of course, there were exceptions. There were numerous Indian Tribes, many who warred against each other, and there were those who attacked white settlements and random westward travelers. However, even when the thousands of westward travelers depleted grazing land and fresh water springs and killed off much of the wild game, including the buffalo, the major Indian leaders agreed to treaties that allowed safe passage (and settlement in some areas) for the white people.

In some of these treaties, the Indians were given settlement lands and hunting grounds in northern Wyoming, Montana and the Dakotas. When some white men tried to go into Montana by way of what was known as the Bozeman Trail (through the mountains from Casper to what is now Bozeman, Montana), they were turned back by the Indians and the United States honored the treaty. However, when gold was discovered in Montana and the Dakotas, the U.S. Army was unsuccessful at keeping the white prospectors out of Indian Territory and all-out war ensued. Thus the battle of the Little Bighorn (named after the Little Bighorn River).

I'm not going to give a detailed account of this battle. Anyone who is interested can find the information online. Suffice it to say that Lt. Col. George Armstrong Custer and his 210 cavalry men didn't have a chance against the 2000 Indian warriors who surrounded them. Custer and all of his men were killed in the battle. Two other groups of Cavalry soldiers were on the periphery of the battleground, however, and were able to document much of what happened and also come in (after the Indians had left with their dead) and bury the men who fell in battle, including several Indian guides. When they did so, they left a marker where each man fell. Some time later, the Cavalry came back, reburied all the bodies in a mass grave (except the officers, whose bodies were taken east; Custer's remains are buried at West Point) and put permanent stone markers where the men fell throughout the battlefield. These markers remain today. A large memorial to the Indians has also been erected and smaller markers (in red stone) for some of the Braves.

This national monument sits in the middle of the Crow Indian Reservation. Included on the property is a (current) Veterans' Administration Cemetery that has no link to the Battle of Little Bighorn, but is, nonetheless, a beautiful and solemn place. The entire area is covered with walking and driving trails and preserves a peace befitting of the events that happened here over 130 years ago.

Tuesday, June 8, 2010

Mormon Handcart Center







Top: looking toward the Mormon Handcart Center from Rattlesnake Pass
Others: scenes of the Mormon Handcart Center


The Mormon Handcart Center and Martin's Cove Information Center sit just to the west of Devil's Gate and Rattlesnake Pass. I didn't take the six-mile round trip hike to Martin's Cove because I didn't feel comfortable being alone on the trail, especially when the weather was threatening thunder storms. I did enjoy the visitors' center and the small pioneer museum however. This is a beautiful and peaceful setting and was another place where many people camped along the trail, not just the Martin and Willie handcart companies. It was also the location of the large Tom Sun Ranch. (The visitors' center is now housed in what was the ranch house.) The setting is much like it was when the pioneers came through here, except for the very perfectly manicured lawn in front of the visitors' center, which seemed very out of place in the setting.

One interesting family note: when I walked into the last room of the visitors' center I took a look at the binder they have with stories of everyone who died in the Martin and Willie handcart companies. There was a story about a little girl named Rhoda Oakey. Her family went on to settle in the Bear Lake Valley, where I found Oakey graves last summer. The story gives me the detail I didn't have. These were definitely relatives of Edward Ockey (despite the spelling difference) because they were baptized at the same time Edward was baptized and came from the same place in England. This gives me yet more research to do.

Rattlesnake Pass





Pioneer names are carved on rocks at Rattlesnake Pass.
Looking toward the mountains in the distance.
The road over Rattlesnake Pass.
Devil's Gate and Rattlesnake Pass are accessible from the Mormon Handcart Center, which sits just on the west side of this rock formation.

Devil's Gate and Rattlesnake Pass







Views of Devil's Gate (the top one is taken from Independence Rock).


Visible from Independence Rock is the rock formation known as Devil's Gate, where the Sweetwater River cuts a very narrow gorge through the rock. To the left of this gorge (looking from the east) is Rattlesnake Pass, where the wagons and carts passed around Devil's Gate (the gorge is too narrow to take wagons through).

Casper, Western Trail Center and Independence Rock







Photographs: Top two are views from the trail center. Bottom picture is of Independence Rock.

Where the city of Casper, Wyoming now sits, all of the overland trails converged to cross the North Platte River and head southwest to the Sweetwater River (a distance of 50 miles without water) and then on to South Pass to cross the mountains. During a period of only about 30 years, almost 500,000 people came through here. Many lost their lives crossing the river. In 1847 Brigham Young had his vanguard group build a ferry boat and left ten men to operate it for the benefit of future pioneers.

The National Historic Trails Interpretive Center in Casper is by far the best pioneer trails museum that I have ever visited. It has sections about each of the groups that went west and the Indians who were already there, as well as a large panorama and film theater that put the entire westward movement in perspective. It is truly amazing that so many people made the arduous journey.

Following the trails southwest from Casper, the next significant trail site is Independence Rock. It was estimated that the wagon trains needed to be to this spot by Independence Day (July 4th) in order to safely reach California or Oregon before winter storms set in. Many travelers wrote their names on this rock.

From the Plains to the Mountains



Photographs: Standing in the same place, looking to the left and to the right (hills on one side, mountains on the other).

Not far (at least by car) west of Fort Laramie, the two lane highway joins with the interstate highway. At this point, looming in front of you is Laramie Mountain. From here on large mountains can be seen looming in the distance. This must have been an incredible sight for the westward pioneers.

Fort Laramie








Views of Fort Laramie and looking westward from it.


Fort Laramie was the saving grace for more than one wagon train. It began as Fort William, a private trading post owned by William Sublette from 1834-1836. The American Fur Company owned it from 1836-1849 (and renamed it Fort John, though it was commonly called Fort Laramie). In 1849 the U.S. Army bought Fort Laramie and made it a military outpost along the Oregon Trail. They built stables, a bakery and officers' and soldiers' quarters to house the two complanies of mounted riflemen and one of infantry that were stationed there.

Fort Laramie was an important stopping place for wagon trains, a place where they could rest and often restock their provisions. It is mentioned in many trail diaries. As troubles with the Indians escalated after 1850, this fort became a strategic outpost for military operations. It is an awesome place to visit today, with some original buildings restored, some in ruins and others rebuilt, so a visitor can get an example of the fort in its many different stages and historical periods. It is also still out in the middle of nowhere, so the area surrounding it looks much like it did when the wagons roaled through on their way west.

Scott's Bluff







Photographs: The view to the west from the top of Scott's Bluff; the view to the east from the top of Scott's Bluff (if you enlarge the picture you can see Chimney Rock in the distance); the pass through Scott's Bluff (with examples of different kinds of wagons used on the trail); Scott's Bluff from a distance.

Scott's Bluff is such an interesting area. It has a pass through the middle of it. It's about 23 miles west of Chimney Rock and you can see one from the other. The Oregon and California Trails went right through this pass (as does the modern-day road), but the Mormon Trail was much further north, so they only saw this formation from a distance. There is a very nice National Park Service visitors' center here. There is a road up to the top of the bluff or you can hike the trail. It's a beautiful place to stop. I think this is one example of a place where the Mormon Trail was an easier route than the other trails. This is also the area where I saw the rattlesnakes.

More Nebraska Rocks




Courthouse and Jail Rocks: These are seen from a distance, as the Mormon pioneers would have seen them. The large one is supposed to be the courthouse and the smaller one next to it the jail.
Chimney Rock: There is a nice visitors' center here with stories and a film about the westward migration and also the geological rock formations in the area.


Rocks in Nebraska







Top photo: Indian Lookout or Frog's Head Bluff. If a person climbs up to the top of this lookout, you can see Chimney Rock in the distance.
Other photos: Ancient Bluff Ruins (named by the Mormon pioneers). Wilford Woodruff wrote the following in his journal May 22, 1847:
The Bluffs on our rout to day have presented the most singular natural senery that I ever beheld in my travels on the earth. It has the greatest appearance of the old walls & ruins of the castles of Europe...



Campsites


There were many common campsites along the trails that were used by the wagon and handcart groups. One was at Ash Hollow (pictured above), where there was plentiful water, grass for the animals and shade (an important commodity along the trail). Other places where groups commonly stopped included Fort Kearney (pronounced karnie), an outpost established in 1848 in central Nebraska, Fort Laramie (eastern Wyoming), and near many of the rock formations (like Independence Rock and Chimney Rock). Over the years of the emigration, some of these campsites turned into dumping grounds for garbage and items too heavy for the wagons and carts. They also had sanitation problems. It is estimated that almost 500,000 people crossed the United States on the Oregon, California and Mormon Trails, so it's easy to understand how campsites could become overused and the land overgrazed along the way.

Animals

I didn't stop to take pictures of animals along the trail, but I did see a great variety of them. The pioneers first encountered bison about midway through Nebraska, though there are none roaming freely there today. I saw many wild turkeys, pheasants, geese, quail and other birds, even a couple of eagles. I saw only a couple of deer, but many pronghorn (antelope), especially in Wyoming. I even saw a mother pronghorn with two very small babies. By the time I got to western Nebraska, every trail site had warning signs about rattlesnakes (another reason to not go out hiking in the brush by myself). Actually, rattlesnakes were not a big problem for the emmigrants in the wagon trains. These snakes are quite shy, not very fast and can't strike from any distance. They are also deaf, so backing away from one very slowly is considered effective at preventing a problem. I did see three rattlesnakes on one of the dirt roads I was driving on last Thursday.

The Overland Trail







Photographs: The North Platte River, the Sand Hills, where the wagons came over the Sand Hills, wagon ruts over the hills.

When I left Omaha last Wednesday, I had intended to head west by way of the Elkhorn River crossing (part of the Mormon Trail), but that was flooded from the storm the day before. Instead, I headed southwest on the interstate highway and picked up the Mormon Trail again at Grand Island, Nebraska.

A note about guidebooks: I cannot say enough in praise of the series of guidebooks published (free) by the National Park Service entitled National Historic Trails: Auto Tour Route Interpretive Guide. There are currently three booklets in this series: "The Mormon Pioneer Trail Across Iowa in 1846", "Nebraska and Northeastern Colorado" and "Across Wyoming". These guides include historic background material, detailed directions to and descriptions of trail markers and interesting locations to stop and see, and also maps that coordinate with the printed information. Though local guide books and Internet sites give some of this information, there are places I would never have known about without these specific guides. I also used a little booklet I bought from the DUP called "Landmarks and Events Along the Historic Mormon Trail" that was very useful. The NPS guide books were available at many stops along the way, but I ordered my by phone from the National Historic Trails office in Salt Lake before leaving on my trip.

The Mormon Trail differs from the Oregon and California Trails specifically in that it stays (mostly) on the north side of the Platte and North Platte Rivers across Nebraska and into Wyoming, while the other trails stay on the south side of the Platte. There were several reasons for this, principally to keep the Saints away from other people (especially Missourians) on the other trails and thus avoid trouble and persecution. It was also healthier for the Saints to travel a different road because the other route became so busy and the campgrounds so overused, that there was more incidence of disease in the other camps due to poor sanitation. Staying to the north also gave the Mormons less competition for fresh water and grazing land for the animals. However, in some places the Mormon route was more difficult and took a little longer. Nevertheless, there were hardships on both routes and eventually, at Fort Laramie and Casper, the routes all came together to head west over South Pass (the only place to get wagons through the Rocky Mountains). After South Pass (in western Wyoming) the routes again separated, with the Mormon Trail heading southwest to the Salt Lake Valley.

It was very interesting to follow the trails west through Nebraska and Wyoming. Though the Mormons forged some new wagon roads on their way, most of the trail roads followed old Indian trails. In 1842, a man named Fremont traveled the West and made extensive detailed maps of the terrain, which were extremely valuable to others who followed (including the Mormons).

Eastern and central Nebraska are flat, and though there are now miles and miles of corn fields, at the time of the pioneer migration there were miles and miles of prairie grass. This initial part of the trip was the easier part, which was a good thing because it gave the people and animals a chance to get to used to the rigors of daily travel. As you drive west you gradually rise in elevation, the air gets dryer and by the time you get into the western third of Nebraska the terrain becomes hilly with rock outcroppings and then large rock formations that were very strange sites to the pioneers. These rock formations also served as trail markers and are mentioned in many of the pioneer diaries (both Mormon and non-Mormon).

One particularly interesting thing to see along the trail is evidence of wagon travel in the form of ruts. When they had to get down a hill, they would lock the wheels of the wagons and carts so as to not go too fast and hurt the animals. Thus the wagons and carts caused deep ruts in the earth that in many places (especially where there was sandstone close to the surface) are still visible today. I saw only a couple of these places because the others require short hikes and I didn't feel comfortable going very far off the road on trails when I was alone. A week or two later in June and there would have been many more tourists, but last week I was pretty much the only person stopping at most of these sites. Should you ever be traveling this way, there are several places where the ruts can be seen.

I'm going to split up my posts on the Mormon Trail so I can put up some of the many pictures I took. I hope you can get a sense for the wildness of it all. Once you get to western Nebraska, it's very easy to imagine what it looked like to the pioneers, because it still looks much the same today.

Monday, June 7, 2010

(More) Winter Quarters







Here are some more photographs from the Winter Quarters cemetery. Top to bottom: (1&2)-the graves (only a few markers, most gravesites are unmarked), (3) the list of names of those who are known to have been buried here, (4) the Fairbanks statue of parents looking into a child's grave (if you walk up close you can see the body of the child in the grave).



Winter Quarters (Florence, Nebraska)








After my frightening experience with the storm in Omaha last Tuesday evening, I was ready to leave the city and its state on Wednesday morning. However, I really wanted to visit the Winter Quarters cemetery in Florence (now part of north-central Omaha). I had been to this site once before, in September of 1965, when I went to Chicago with Mom and Dad and we drove home in the new Mercedes they had purchased in Germany that summer. As I drove up the hill to the cemetery last Wednesday, it all looked very familiar to me, until I rounded the corner and saw the new Winter Quarters temple. I was amazed at how the (very small) temple backs right up next to the cemetery and yet holds a place of its own on the small hillside. The temple is beautiful, with narrow vertical stained glass windows that you can almost reach out and touch through the cemetery's wrought iron fencing. It seems fitting in this historic setting.

The entire site is significant for two main historical events (or time periods). First, this is where the main body of Saints gathered in the summer and fall of 1846, after leaving Nauvoo and crossing Iowa. For that winter and the next, Winter Quarters was a bustling settlement of people preparing to go west. It was on Indian land, with an agreement that the Mormons could be there for only two years. Even that first winter, many of the Saints were spread out in small settlements to the north, south and east, especially across the river in Iowa. But Winter Quarters was the jumping-off point for the first two years of the Mormon movement west, and this is where the Billings, Patten and Ockey families spent at least part of that winter of 1846-1847. It is here, in this cemetery, that John Patten is buried, along with his granddaughter Rachel Patten (daughter of Peggy and Charles), who died of measles at only two years of age. Isaac Morley's first wife, Lucy Gunn, is also buried here, as is Eliza Ockey (spelled Oakey on the memorial), first wife of Edward Ockey. Their names are listed with the many others under the statue (by Avard Fairbanks) of pioneer parents peering into the grave of a young child. It is a moving tribute to those who died and those who had to go on without them.

The second time period that gives this site historical significance is that of the handcart pioneers. Florence, Nebraska served as the jumping-off point for a number of these groups, including the company in which Catherine Farrar (Wheelwright) and her sister Sarah traveled. An almost-life-sized statue of a family with a handcart stands in front of the visitors' center, across the street from the cemetery and the temple. The visitors' center itself has a nice exhibit explaining both the Winter Quarters settlement and the story of the handcart companies. (Unfortunately, I was unable to spend very much time in the visitors' center because one of the young sister missionaries was wearing heavy perfume.)

This is a beautiful spot, and I am glad for the hour I spent here, but because it sits in the middle of what is now a big city, it is a little hard to imagine what it must have been like as wilderness. It wasn't until I got out of the city and headed west across Nebraska that I could really appreciate how wild it really was at that time.